A question decided before the merits, and often decisive of them.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of August 2022
Where a dispute touches several states, the forum applies its own choice-of-law
rules to determine the governing substantive law.
Contractual choice. Generally honored where the chosen state has a
substantial relationship to the parties or the transaction, or another
reasonable basis exists, and application would not contravene a fundamental
policy of a state with a materially greater interest.
Absent a clause. Most states apply a most significant relationship analysis
weighing the place of contracting, negotiation, performance, the location of the
subject matter, and the parties’ domiciles, against general policy factors.
Others retain older rules — the place of contracting for contract questions and
the place of injury for torts.
Depeçage. Different issues in the same case may be governed by different
states’ law, so the analysis is issue by issue rather than case by case.
Scope of a clause. A clause selecting the law governing the agreement may
not reach related tort claims unless drafted to cover disputes arising out of or
relating to the agreement.
Statutes of limitation are procedural in traditional analysis and governed by
the forum, subject to borrowing statutes. Contractual choice of law does not
always carry the limitation period with it, and clauses should say whether it
does.
Public policy overrides remain, notably for restrictive covenants, consumer
protections and wage statutes.