Trial courts, appellate courts, and which one hears what.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of March 2023
Understanding court structure is the first step in assessing where a dispute
will be heard and what review is available.
State systems. Generally a trial court of general jurisdiction, courts of
limited jurisdiction for smaller claims and specific subject matter, an
intermediate appellate court, and a court of last resort. Some states have
specialized business courts with judges assigned to commercial cases, which
materially affects how a complex commercial matter proceeds.
Federal system. District courts as trial courts; courts of appeals organized
by circuit; and the Supreme Court, whose review is discretionary. Bankruptcy
courts are units of the district courts, and magistrate judges handle
substantial portions of civil litigation by consent or by referral.
Subject matter jurisdiction. State courts are courts of general
jurisdiction. Federal courts require a federal question or diversity of
citizenship with the requisite amount, and a handful of exclusive grants —
bankruptcy, patent, admiralty, certain securities and antitrust matters.
Concurrent jurisdiction means many disputes could be brought in either
system, which makes forum choice a strategic decision about procedure, jury
pools, speed and appellate law.
Administrative tribunals hear specified categories — tax appeals,
unemployment, workers compensation, professional licensing — with judicial
review afterwards on a deferential standard.