When a customer list is protectable, and when it is not.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of March 2023
Customer information is the most frequently claimed and most frequently
contested category of trade secret.
Not protectable. The identity of customers in an industry where they are
readily ascertainable from directories, trade publications or observation. A
list of hospitals in a region is not a secret.
Potentially protectable. Compilations containing information not publicly
available and developed at expense — specific contacts and their roles,
negotiated pricing, contract expiry dates, purchasing patterns, requirements,
credit terms and preferences.
Effort and expense in developing the compilation is what courts examine, and
evidence of it should be preserved.
Memory. Jurisdictions differ on whether information an employee remembers,
as opposed to takes, can be misappropriated. Several protect the information
regardless of the medium; others treat memorized general customer knowledge as
the employee’s own.
Contractual protection through non-solicitation covenants is more reliable
than trade secret protection for customer relationships, and is enforceable in
more states than a non-compete.
Practical measures. Restrict access to the full customer database, log
exports, disable bulk export for most users, and treat a large export shortly
before a resignation as the significant event it is.