Who the duty runs to, and the decisions that get examined.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of June 2023
As a company approaches insolvency, the question of whose interests the board
must serve becomes acute.
The prevailing view. Directors of an insolvent company continue to owe
duties to the corporation, and creditors may enforce those duties derivatively
because they become the residual claimants. There is generally no direct duty
owed to individual creditors.
Deepening insolvency as an independent cause of action has been rejected in
most jurisdictions, though the underlying conduct may support fiduciary or
fraudulent transfer claims.
Business judgment protection continues. Directors may pursue a reasonable
strategy to save the company, and taking risk is not a breach.
What gets examined. Continued trading while unable to pay; payments to
insiders and affiliates; grants of new security for old debt; transfers of
opportunities to a related entity; and compensation increases.
Practical steps. Increase board meeting frequency; obtain independent
advice; document the alternatives considered and the basis for the choice;
consider a restructuring committee of disinterested directors; monitor the
solvency analysis with real numbers rather than assumptions; and confirm
directors and officers insurance including run-off.
Personal exposure for unpaid payroll taxes and, in many states, unpaid
wages, which is not discharged by the entity’s insolvency.