Agreeing how electronic discovery will actually be run, before anyone spends the money.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of November 2023
An ESI protocol is a negotiated or court-entered order governing how
electronically stored information is preserved, collected, searched and
produced. It is the single most effective cost control in document-heavy
litigation.
What it should cover. Custodians and non-custodial sources. Date ranges.
Data types included and excluded — email, chat, mobile messages, collaboration
platforms, voicemail, structured databases. Search methodology, whether keywords,
technology-assisted review, or both. Deduplication and email threading.
Production format and metadata fields. Handling of privilege, including
claw-back.
Claw-back and the non-waiver order. An order providing that production does
not waive privilege, entered under the applicable evidence rule, protects
against inadvertent disclosure and against the argument that a broad production
waived the subject matter. Getting one entered early is close to costless.
Modern message sources are the live issue. Ephemeral messaging, chat
platforms and personal devices generate data that is easy to lose and hard to
collect. Address them expressly; silence is read as an assumption they were
covered.
Negotiate early, revisit once. Protocols agreed before anyone knows the data
landscape often need one amendment. Build in a meet-and-confer mechanism so that
amendment does not require motion practice.