Structures that work, and transfers that are undone.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of December 2023
Businesses and owners structure their affairs to limit exposure, and the line
between lawful planning and a voidable transfer is timing and intent.
Lawful planning. Entity structures separating operations from assets;
adequate insurance; retirement accounts within statutory protections; homestead
exemptions; tenancy by the entireties where recognized; and buy-sell
arrangements. All of these are effective when established before a claim arises.
Voidable transfers. Moves made after a claim exists, or in anticipation of
one, are analyzed under fraudulent transfer law using the badges of fraud —
insider transferees, retention of control, concealment, the timing relative to
threatened litigation, and inadequate consideration.
Self-settled trusts. Domestic asset protection trusts are recognized in some
states and their effectiveness against creditors of a non-resident settlor, and
in bankruptcy, is contested.
Offshore structures carry reporting obligations with severe penalties, and
courts have used contempt to compel repatriation, with the impossibility defense
rejected where the debtor created the impossibility.
Practical guidance. Structure early, document the business purpose, maintain
formalities, and do not move assets after a claim is on the horizon. Planning
undertaken in the shadow of a dispute usually makes the position worse.