The default is that a municipality cannot be sued in tort. The exceptions are narrow and specific.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of April 2024
Most states grant governmental agencies broad immunity from tort liability when
engaged in a governmental function, subject to enumerated statutory exceptions.
Pleading around immunity, not merely alleging negligence, is what makes a claim
viable.
Governmental function is generally defined expansively as any activity
expressly or impliedly authorized by law, which means the immunity covers most
of what a municipality does. Proprietary functions — activities conducted
primarily for pecuniary profit and not normally supported by taxes — fall
outside it.
Typical statutory exceptions. Defective highways and streets within the
agency’s jurisdiction; negligent operation of a government-owned motor vehicle;
dangerous or defective conditions in public buildings; sewage disposal system
events; and medical care at government hospitals. Each has its own elements and
notice rules.
Individual employees. Officers and employees are commonly immune for
discretionary acts undertaken in good faith within the scope of authority, with
a lower threshold — often gross negligence as the proximate cause — for the
lowest tier of employees.
Pleading. In many jurisdictions immunity is not an affirmative defense but a
characteristic of the claim, so the complaint must plead facts placing the case
within an exception or it is dismissed.
Notice. Short statutory notice periods apply to several exceptions and are
strictly enforced.