Who pays for what, to whom, and whether it covers the other side’s legal fees.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of May 2024
An indemnity shifts a defined risk from one party to another: A agrees to cover
B’s losses arising from specified events. The clauses are long, negotiated late,
and frequently misread.
Points that decide their effect:
Scope of triggering events. Third-party claims only, or also direct claims
between the parties? Many indemnities are drafted for third-party claims and are
then invoked, unsuccessfully, in a dispute between the signatories.
Defense obligations. A duty to defend is broader than a duty to indemnify and
arises earlier — often on the allegation rather than the outcome — and it
includes control of counsel, which parties fight over.
Caps, baskets and survival. Whether liability is capped, whether small claims
must accumulate before any is payable, and how long the obligation lasts after
closing.
Fees. Whether the indemnity covers attorneys’ fees, which in a jurisdiction
following the American rule is often the most valuable part of it.
Negligence. Whether the indemnity covers the indemnified party’s own
negligence. Many states require that to be stated in clear and specific terms,
and a general clause will not achieve it.