The theories borrowers raise, and the conduct that supports them.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of September 2024
Lender liability claims are usually defensive, raised in response to
enforcement. They rarely succeed and they reliably delay collection.
Breach of contract. Failure to fund a committed facility, improper
acceleration, failure to give required notice, or breach of a forbearance
agreement.
Breach of the implied covenant of good faith. Not a free-standing obligation
to act in the borrower’s interest; a limit on the exercise of contractual
discretion. Where a loan document gives the lender discretion — over reserves,
over eligibility, over consent — the covenant constrains its arbitrary exercise.
Control. A lender that participates in the borrower’s operational decisions
may be found to have assumed a duty, or in extreme cases to be an alter ego.
Approving a budget is not control; directing which vendors are paid approaches
it.
Fraud and misrepresentation from assurances about renewal or additional
credit.
Tortious interference with the borrower’s relationships.
Prevention. Written communications, express reservations of rights, no oral
commitments, a documented credit decision process, and consistency between what
the file says and what the relationship manager said.