A creditor’s remedy that reaches distributions but usually not control.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of October 2024
A judgment creditor of a member cannot ordinarily seize the member’s interest in
an LLC or partnership. The remedy is a charging order.
What it does. Constitutes a lien on the debtor’s transferable interest and
requires the entity to pay to the creditor any distributions that would
otherwise go to the debtor. The creditor becomes a passive assignee of
distributions.
What it does not do. Confer management or voting rights, access to
information, or the ability to compel a distribution. Where the entity makes no
distributions, the creditor receives nothing.
Exclusive remedy. Many statutes provide that the charging order is the sole
remedy, expressly foreclosing foreclosure of the interest and judicial
dissolution at a creditor’s instance. Others permit foreclosure on a showing
that distributions will not satisfy the judgment within a reasonable time,
after which the purchaser holds a transferable interest.
Single-member LLCs. Several courts have held that charging order protection
does not apply, or applies with less force, where there are no other members to
protect. Statutes in some states address this expressly.
Tax consideration. A creditor holding a charging order may be allocated
taxable income without receiving cash, which is a recognized negotiating point.
Practical significance. Charging order protection is a principal reason
operating businesses and investment assets are held in LLCs.