Loan workouts: forbearance without giving away the file
A forbearance agreement can preserve a lender position or quietly reset it. The difference is in the recitals.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of November 2024
When a borrower defaults, a negotiated workout is usually better for both sides
than immediate enforcement. It is also where lenders inadvertently weaken their
position.
Document the default first. A forbearance agreement should recite the
existing defaults, the amounts due, and the borrower’s acknowledgment of both.
Without that, the agreement can be argued to have waived or cured what preceded
it.
Reaffirm the loan documents and the guaranties. A modification made without
the guarantor’s consent can, depending on the terms and the jurisdiction, release
the guarantor. This is one of the most common and most expensive oversights in
the field.
Say what forbearance is not. It is a temporary agreement not to exercise
remedies, not a waiver of them, not a cure, and not a course of dealing. State
that expressly, and state that no further forbearance is implied.
Watch for lender liability exposure. A lender that goes beyond the credit
relationship — directing the borrower’s operations, controlling disbursements to
particular vendors, making commitments it does not honor — can find itself
facing claims of control, breach of good faith, or interference. The line is
between enforcing rights and running the business.
Take the opportunity to improve the position. Additional collateral, a
confession of judgment where permitted, updated financial reporting, and
reaffirmed waivers are all normally available in exchange for time.