Two statutes of extraordinary breadth, and the reason nearly every white collar case includes one.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of November 2024
Mail and wire fraud prohibit the use of the mails or interstate wires in
furtherance of a scheme to defraud. Their breadth makes them the default
charging tools in federal white collar practice.
Elements. A scheme to defraud, involving a material misrepresentation or
omission; intent to defraud; and use of the mails or interstate wires in
furtherance of the scheme. The mailing or wire need not itself be fraudulent —
a routine confirmation email suffices.
Materiality means having a natural tendency to influence, or being capable of
influencing, the decision of the person to whom it is addressed.
Property. The object of the scheme must be money or property. Courts have
repeatedly narrowed theories that treat regulatory interests, or the right to
accurate information, as property.
Honest services fraud is a distinct theory limited by decision to bribery
and kickback schemes.
Good faith is a complete defense, because the offense requires intent to
defraud. Reliance on advice of counsel, where genuinely sought and followed on
full disclosure, is a recognized route to negating intent.
Each use is a count, which is how a single scheme becomes a multi-count
indictment and how the guidelines calculation escalates.
Conspiracy and aiding and abetting extend liability to participants who
never sent anything themselves.