Identifying the genuine dispute, and supporting it properly.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of April 2025
An opposition succeeds by identifying a genuine dispute of material fact,
supported by admissible evidence.
Respond to the statement of facts paragraph by paragraph, admitting what is
true, disputing what is not, and citing the record for every dispute. Failure to
respond properly results in the fact being deemed admitted, which decides many
motions.
Material means it could affect the outcome under the governing law. Disputes
about immaterial facts do not defeat the motion, and an opposition that
manufactures them signals weakness.
Genuine means a reasonable factfinder could resolve it in the non-movant’s
favor. A scintilla is not enough.
Evidence, not argument. Declarations on personal knowledge, deposition
testimony, authenticated documents, and responses to discovery. Counsel’s
assertions in a brief are not evidence.
Additional facts. A statement of additional facts precluding judgment, which
frames the case for trial.
Request more discovery where the opposition cannot be presented without it,
by affidavit specifying what is sought, why it is not available, and how it
would create a dispute. This is granted where the motion was filed early and
denied where discovery has closed.
Cross-motions where the facts are truly undisputed and the law favors you.