False statements that cost a business customers, and the special damages problem.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of August 2026
A business injured by false statements has two related claims with different
requirements.
Defamation concerns statements about the business or its principals that
harm reputation. Statements imputing dishonesty, insolvency or incompetence in
trade are often actionable without proof of specific loss.
Trade libel, or commercial disparagement, concerns false statements about
the quality or ownership of goods or services. It requires proof of special
damages — identifiable lost sales — and, in most formulations, malice or intent
to cause harm. That damages requirement defeats most claims, because businesses
rarely can trace specific lost customers.
Truth is a complete defense, and substantial truth suffices.
Opinion is protected, but a statement framed as opinion that implies
undisclosed defamatory facts is not.
Privileges. Statements to regulators, in litigation, and among those with a
common interest are qualifiedly or absolutely privileged depending on context.
Online reviews. Platforms are generally protected from liability for user
content, so the claim runs against the author. Anonymous authors require a
subpoena and, in many states, a threshold showing before the platform must
identify them.
Strategic caution. Suing a critic frequently amplifies the statement, and
anti-SLAPP statutes in many states permit early dismissal with a fee award
against the plaintiff.