What the court must state, and how it is reviewed.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of September 2026
In a case tried without a jury, the court must find the facts specially and
state its conclusions of law separately.
Purpose. To provide the parties with the basis for the decision and the
appellate court with a record permitting review. Findings that recite the
evidence without resolving it, or that adopt one party’s proposal verbatim,
attract criticism and occasionally reversal.
Proposed findings. Courts frequently ask the parties to submit them.
Proposals should be drafted as findings the court could adopt — specific, tied
to the evidence with citations, and free of argument.
Review. Findings of fact are reviewed for clear error, with due regard for
the trial court’s opportunity to judge credibility. Conclusions of law are
reviewed independently, and mixed questions according to their character.
Insufficient findings. Where findings are inadequate to permit review, the
usual disposition is a remand for further findings rather than reversal, which
costs a year.
Credibility. A finding that a witness was not credible is close to
unreviewable, which is why the trial is the last opportunity on contested facts.
Amendment. A motion to amend or make additional findings within the
post-judgment window, which is also the vehicle for identifying an omitted issue
before the appeal.