When there is no enforceable contract, the law sometimes still requires payment for what was received.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of September 2026
Unjust enrichment is a claim in restitution: the defendant received a benefit at
the plaintiff’s expense, in circumstances where retaining it without payment
would be unjust. Quantum meruit is the related claim for the reasonable value of
services rendered.
It is a fallback, not an alternative. Where an express contract governs the
same subject matter, the claim is ordinarily barred — the parties have already
allocated the risk. So the claim appears where the contract is unenforceable,
void, terminated, or never quite formed.
Typical settings. Work performed under a letter of intent while the
definitive agreement was still being negotiated. Services rendered to a party
who is not the contract counterparty. Improvements to property under an
agreement that fails for the statute of frauds. Payments made by mistake.
Measure of recovery is the value of the benefit conferred, not the
plaintiff’s expectation. That is often less than the contract would have paid,
which is why it is a fallback.
Pleading in the alternative is permitted and is standard practice: contract
claim first, restitution second, with an acknowledgment that success on the
first forecloses the second.
Prevention. For anyone doing work before the paperwork is signed, the answer
is a short written interim agreement covering scope, rate and what happens if
the deal dies. Relying on restitution to fix a missing contract is a poor
substitute for having one.