What to ask, what to listen for, and the limits on strikes.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of October 2026
Jury selection is the only part of trial where the lawyer learns rather than
tells, and the questions should be designed accordingly.
Purpose. Identify jurors who cannot be fair, and gather information for
peremptory challenges. Persuasion during voir dire is limited and, in many
courts, prohibited.
Cause challenges are unlimited and require a demonstrated inability to be
impartial. Rehabilitation — asking whether the juror can set the view aside — is
what defeats most cause challenges, so the questioning should establish the
depth of the view rather than merely its existence.
Peremptory challenges are limited in number and may not be exercised on the
basis of race, ethnicity or sex. A challenge to the strike requires a prima
facie showing, a neutral explanation, and a ruling on pretext.
Open questions. Ask what jurors think, not whether they can be fair. The
useful answers come from questions about experience: dealings with businesses of
this kind, views on lawsuits between companies, experience with contracts,
attitudes toward large organizations.
Written questionnaires are worth requesting in long or sensitive cases.
Listen for the leader. Deliberations are shaped disproportionately by one or
two jurors, and identifying them matters more than any single answer.