Recovering incentive pay after a restatement or misconduct.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of September 2022
Clawback provisions permit an employer to recover compensation already paid.
They arise from listing standards, statute, and contract.
Listing standard clawbacks. Listed issuers must maintain and enforce a
policy recovering erroneously awarded incentive compensation received by current
and former executive officers during a lookback period following an accounting
restatement. Recovery is required regardless of fault, with narrow impracticability
exceptions, and issuers may not indemnify against it.
Statutory clawbacks apply to certain officers following restatements caused
by misconduct, and to particular industries.
Contractual clawbacks in employment agreements and incentive plans, covering
misconduct, restatement, breach of restrictive covenants, and competing after
departure. These are the broadest and depend entirely on drafting.
Enforceability issues. State wage laws restrict recovery of paid wages in
some jurisdictions, which is why clawback provisions target bonus and equity
rather than salary and often operate by forfeiture of unvested amounts rather
than by demanding repayment.
Practical drafting. Define the triggering events precisely; specify the
compensation subject to recovery and the lookback period; provide for
set-off where lawful; state the governing law; and require the executive to
acknowledge the policy in the award agreement, which is the mechanism that makes
later adoption binding.