Who owns what an employee creates, and the statutes that limit how far assignment can reach.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of September 2023
Absent agreement, ownership of employee-created intellectual property is
governed by default rules that frequently disappoint employers.
Copyright. Works prepared by an employee within the scope of employment are
works made for hire, owned by the employer. Works by independent contractors are
not, unless they fall within enumerated categories and there is a signed written
agreement — which is why contractor agreements need express assignments.
Patents. An invention belongs to the inventor unless assigned. The
employer’s shop right — a non-exclusive license where company time and resources
were used — is a poor substitute for ownership.
Assignment agreements should use present-tense assignment language, because
a promise to assign in the future has been held to create only an equitable
obligation that can be defeated by a later actual assignment to someone else.
Statutory limits. Several states void assignment provisions covering
inventions developed entirely on the employee’s own time without company
equipment or trade secrets and unrelated to the business, and require written
notice of the limitation to employees. Overbroad clauses in those states risk
invalidity.
Disclosure obligations and a prior inventions schedule signed at hire prevent
later disputes about what the employee brought with them.
Moral rights and open source obligations should be addressed for engineering
and creative roles.