A tenant who stays past the term creates a new tenancy, and the terms may not be the ones anyone expected.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of April 2024
When a lease term ends and the tenant remains, the resulting arrangement depends
on the lease, the landlord’s response, and state law.
Landlord’s election. Traditionally, the landlord may treat the holdover as a
trespasser and evict, or elect to hold the tenant to a new tenancy. Once the
election is made — usually by accepting rent — it binds.
Term of the new tenancy. Depending on the jurisdiction, it may be
month-to-month, or a periodic tenancy measured by how rent was paid, or in some
older authorities a new term of up to a year. Modern commercial leases specify
month-to-month to avoid the uncertainty.
Holdover rent. Commercial leases commonly provide for holdover rent at a
multiple of the last base rent, plus consequential damages where the landlord
has a succeeding tenant. Multiples of one and a half to two are common and
generally enforced; punitive multiples may be attacked as penalties.
Consequential damages for delaying a new tenant’s occupancy are the real
exposure and are frequently excluded elsewhere in the lease. If the landlord
wants them, the holdover clause must carve them back in.
Practical handling. Send written notice before expiry stating the position;
avoid accepting rent without a reservation of rights letter; and if an extension
is being negotiated, document that occupancy pending agreement is on stated
terms.