A non-compete case is usually decided in the first three weeks, on incomplete evidence.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of June 2024
When an employee leaves for a competitor, the dispute rarely proceeds to trial.
It is resolved at the preliminary injunction stage, quickly, and the ruling
usually determines the commercial outcome regardless of the eventual merits.
Speed cuts both ways. An employer that waits weeks after learning of the
departure undermines its own claim of irreparable harm. One that moves within
days signals that the harm is real.
Irreparable harm is the contested element. Lost revenue is compensable in
money and therefore not irreparable. What is argued instead is loss of customer
relationships and goodwill, and disclosure or use of confidential information —
harms that resist measurement. Concrete evidence matters far more than assertion:
a customer who has moved, a download of files before resignation, a solicitation
email.
Forensics decide many of these cases. Access logs, mass downloads to
external drives, and cloud sync activity in the final days of employment are the
most persuasive evidence available and are often the reason an injunction is
granted.
Bonds. A party obtaining an injunction is generally required to post
security, and where the injunction stops someone earning a living the amount can
be substantial.
For the departing employee: what you take matters more than where you go. The
cases that go badly are almost always the ones involving copied files.