Consistency, statutory formalities, and the benefit plan question.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of September 2024
An employer conducting more than an isolated termination should design the
severance program before making selections.
Consistency. A formula based on objective factors — service, level,
compensation — applied uniformly. Ad hoc negotiation invites comparison claims
and discrimination arguments.
Benefit plan status. A severance arrangement requiring ongoing
administrative discretion may constitute an employee benefit plan subject to
federal plan rules, which brings reporting, claims procedures and, importantly,
federal preemption of state law claims and a deferential standard of review.
Structuring the program as a plan is often advantageous, and doing so requires
a written document and summary description.
Releases. Consideration beyond what is already owed. Statutory formalities
for age claims, including the extended consideration and revocation periods and,
for group terminations, disclosure of the decisional unit with job titles and
ages.
Carve-outs. Rights that cannot be released — agency charges, workers
compensation, unemployment, vested benefits, and protected communications with
regulators — should be stated to keep the release enforceable.
Confidentiality and non-disparagement drafted with awareness of restrictions
on such terms in severance agreements.
Notice statutes. Assess mass layoff notice thresholds before finalizing the
list, since the count determines whether sixty days of notice is required.