Knew or should have known is the standard, and it survives a policy that says do not do it.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of March 2025
An employer must pay for work it suffers or permits. A rule prohibiting
unrecorded work does not excuse payment where management knew, or with
reasonable diligence should have known, that work was occurring.
Common sources. Answering messages outside shift hours, booting systems
before clock-in, closing duties after clock-out, travel between job sites,
mandatory training, and remote work performed around childcare hours.
Remote and mobile work has enlarged the problem. Access logs, message
timestamps and VPN records provide the evidence that an employer should have
known, and they are discoverable.
Reasonable diligence generally means having a reasonable reporting procedure
and not preventing or discouraging its use. An employer that provides a channel,
publicizes it, pays every report promptly, and disciplines managers who
discourage reporting is in a strong position.
Discipline for unauthorized work is permitted — but the time must still be
paid. Those are separate questions and conflating them is the classic error.
De minimis doctrine has narrowed considerably as time-tracking technology has
improved; small increments that are regularly worked and readily recordable are
increasingly compensable.
Audit periodically. Compare access logs against time records for a sample
period. Finding the gap internally costs far less than finding it in a
collective action.