Preparing the trial record with the appeal in mind
Decisions at trial that determine what an appellate court can do.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of September 2026
The appellate record is created in the trial court, and several habits
materially improve what is available later.
Specific objections. State the rule and the ground. A general objection
preserves nothing but a claim that the evidence was inadmissible for some
reason.
Offers of proof. When evidence is excluded, state on the record what it
would have shown, with the exhibit marked. Without this, prejudice cannot be
demonstrated.
Obtain rulings. An objection taken under advisement and never ruled on
preserves nothing unless counsel returns to it.
Sidebars on the record. If a conference occurs off the record, summarize it
on the record afterwards and confirm the court’s ruling.
Motions for judgment as a matter of law. Made at the close of the opponent’s
case and at the close of all evidence, specifying the elements not proved, and
renewed after the verdict. Sufficiency challenges are lost here more often than
anywhere else.
Jury instructions. Submit proposed instructions, object with grounds before
the jury retires, and ensure the conference is transcribed.
Verdict forms. Special interrogatories preserve the ability to show which
theory the jury adopted.
Exhibits. Confirm what was admitted, what was refused, and that the clerk’s
list matches counsel’s.