Charging for service, and the rules that keep a rate from becoming a tax.
Esshaki Legal Media TeamCurrent as of October 2026
Municipalities that operate water, sewer and other utilities set rates by
ordinance, and those rates are constrained.
Fee or tax. A charge that exceeds the cost of service, is not proportionate
to the benefit received, or is not voluntary may be recharacterized as a tax
requiring voter approval under state tax limitation provisions. The distinction
has generated substantial litigation and refunds.
Cost of service studies are the defense. Rates should be supported by an
analysis allocating costs among classes, including capital replacement, with
documented methodology and periodic updates.
Reserves. Accumulating reserves is legitimate for capital planning and
becomes vulnerable when it is untethered to an identified plan.
Ready-to-serve and connection charges must reflect the costs they recover;
connection charges that fund general capital improvements resemble impact fees
and attract the same analysis.
Shut-off and collection. Due process requires notice and an opportunity to
contest before termination of service, and many states restrict shut-offs
seasonally or for vulnerable households.
Franchise agreements with private utilities and telecommunications providers
govern use of the rights-of-way. Federal law constrains what may be charged and
required for telecommunications and cable, including shot clocks for wireless
facility applications and limits on fees.