Valuing an interest in a private company usually begins with the value of the whole enterprise, then adjusts. Two adjustments dominate the argument.

Discount for lack of control, sometimes called a minority discount, reflects that a holder who cannot direct distributions, compensation or a sale owns something worth less per unit than a controlling stake.

Discount for lack of marketability reflects the absence of a ready market — a private interest cannot be sold in three days at a quoted price.

Whether they apply depends on the purpose of the valuation. In statutory appraisal and many oppression buyouts, fair value is generally the holder’s proportionate share of the enterprise, and discounts are excluded — the theory being that the wrongdoer should not profit from the illiquidity it created. In a fair market value determination for tax or a voluntary sale, they are standard.

Magnitude. Empirical studies support marketability discounts across a wide range, and the choice of study, restricted stock or pre-IPO, moves the number substantially. Control premiums are similarly contested.

Contractual override. A buy-sell agreement can specify whether discounts apply. Doing so removes the largest single variable in a future dispute and costs one sentence at formation.

Expert selection matters accordingly: this is the issue on which valuation experts most often diverge by multiples.