Business valuation combines defined methodology with a substantial number of judgment calls, and the judgment calls are where experts diverge.

Income approach. Discounted cash flow, or capitalization of earnings for stable businesses. Inputs are projected cash flows, a discount rate built from a risk-free rate plus equity risk, size and company-specific premiums, and a terminal value. The company-specific premium is largely judgment and often moves the result by a wide margin.

Market approach. Multiples from comparable public companies or from transactions in comparable private companies. Comparability is contested, and private transaction databases carry known limitations.

Asset approach. Adjusted net asset value, appropriate for holding companies and for businesses worth less as a going concern than in liquidation.

Normalization adjustments. Owner compensation to market, discretionary expenses, related-party rents to market, non-recurring items, and non-operating assets. In closely held companies these adjustments frequently exceed reported earnings.

Standard of value. Fair market value, fair value, investment value and liquidation value give different answers on identical facts, and the applicable standard is set by the statute or the agreement, not by the appraiser.

Valuation date matters, particularly where it precedes or follows the conduct in dispute. It should be fixed at the outset.